CPU Hunter

All models › small SUVs › Subaru Forester

Subaru Forester Years to Avoid? What NHTSA Complaints Show

The 2019 Forester drew 3.9 times the complaints of a typical Forester year. Owners filed 834 complaints about it with NHTSA, against a median of 215 for the model. Problems with the visibility and wiper came up most, in 370 of them. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 8,000 miles. The 2015 and 2020 also stand out.

These are complaints owners filed with NHTSA, not verified failures, and they aren't adjusted for how many of each year were sold. We compare Forester years with each other, never with other models. How we count.

typical year = 1.0×2005: 93 complaints, 0.43× the typical year052006: 88 complaints, 0.41× the typical year062007: 74 complaints, 0.34× the typical year072008: 50 complaints, 0.23× the typical year082009: 178 complaints, 0.83× the typical year092010: 262 complaints, 1.22× the typical year102011: 147 complaints, 0.68× the typical year112012: 107 complaints, 0.5× the typical year122013: 78 complaints, 0.36× the typical year132014: 403 complaints, 1.87× the typical year142015: 617 complaints, 2.87× the typical year152016: 416 complaints, 1.93× the typical year162017: 594 complaints, 2.76× the typical year172018: 499 complaints, 2.32× the typical year182019: 834 complaints, 3.88× the typical year192020: 604 complaints, 2.81× the typical year202021: 215 complaints, 1× the typical year212022: 100 complaints, 0.47× the typical year222023: 76 complaints, 0.35× the typical year232024: 31 complaints, 0.14× the typical year242025: 102 complaints, 0.47× the typical year252026: 35 complaints, 0.16× the typical year26
Complaints filed with NHTSA per model year, divided by the median year of this model (2005–2021). Grey bars: fewer than 30 complaints, or 2022 and newer, too recent to compare. Labels are model years ('17 = 2017).

Which Forester Years Have the Most Complaints?

2019 Forester: Visibility/Wiper Problems

Owners reported a crash, fire or injury in 42 of them. There are 3 recalls on this model year.

One 2019 Forester owner in Colorado had the windshield replaced three months after purchase because of a rock chip. Nine months later, an 8-inch crack "spontaneously appeared with no known cause." That was at 20,143 miles. Another owner wrote that a crack ran more than a foot from the driver's side to the middle, with "no impact from rock or other road debris." It happened at 30,000 miles. None of the year's recalls covers the glass.

Owners mention the engine in 126 complaints. Recall 19V856000 is the year's only engine recall. An aluminum PCV valve can come apart and send pieces into the engine, causing a loss of power while driving. Dealers replace the valve for free, and if the pieces can't be found, they replace the short block engine. Recall 21V263000 covers rear stabilizer bracket bolts that can loosen and come off. Dealers tighten them and replace any missing bolts at no charge.

ComponentComplaintsMedian miles
Visibility/Wiper3708,000
Unknown Or Other1446,600
Electrical System1348,700
Recalls for the 2019 Forester (3)
  • 19V065000 · Steering · 2019-02-06. Loss of power steering assist would require higher steering effort, increasing the risk of a crash.
  • 19V856000 · Engine And Engine Cooling · 2019-12-02. An unexpected loss of power while driving can increase the risk of a crash.
  • 21V263000 · Suspension · 2021-04-15. Missing bolts may allow the rear stabilizer bracket to shift, increasing the risk of a crash.

NHTSA complaints cited above: No. 11324509, filed May 2020, Missouri · No. 11302136, filed Jan. 2020, Colorado.

See the 2019 Subaru Forester on NHTSA

2015 Forester: Engine Problems

The 2015 drew 617 complaints. That's 2.9 times a typical Forester year. Owners reported a crash, fire or injury in 61 of them. There are 3 recalls on this model year.

Owners mention acceleration, hesitation or lost power in 136 complaints about the 2015 Forester. A Rhode Island owner wrote that the SUV lost the ability to accelerate twice on the highway at about 65 mph. The RPMs climbed when the owner pressed the pedal, but "it simply slowed down." That was at 55,000 miles. Another owner said the car "hesitates and stumbles on acceleration" at intersections and stop signs, at 18,600 miles. Dealers told that owner there was no problem.

There's an air bag recall on the 2015, too. Owners mention air bags in 114 complaints. Recall 19V701000 covers 2015-2018 Foresters with heated seats, where a connection in the front passenger seat can loosen. That can switch off the passenger air bag even with someone in the seat. Dealers inspect the sensor mat harness and replace it if needed, free of charge. A second recall, 19V149000, replaces a brake light switch that can keep the brake lights off, stop keyless models from starting and leave the transmission stuck in Park.

ComponentComplaintsMedian miles
Engine13146,300
Air Bags10259,900
Power Train9551,100
Recalls for the 2015 Forester (3)
  • 16V162000 · Engine And Engine Cooling · 2016-03-21. An engine stall increases the risk of a crash.
  • 19V149000 · Exterior Lighting · 2019-02-28. Brake lights that do not illuminate properly will not alert other drivers that the vehicle is slowing or stopping, increasing the risk of crash.
  • 19V701000 · Air Bags · 2019-10-03. If the connection loosens, the front passenger airbag may deactivate even though the seat is occupied, increasing the risk of injury to the front passenger in the event of a crash.

NHTSA complaints cited above: No. 11299582, filed Jan. 2020, Rhode Island · No. 10863711, filed May 2016, Massachusetts.

See the 2015 Subaru Forester on NHTSA

2020 Forester: Visibility/Wiper Problems

The 2020 drew 604 complaints. That's 2.8 times a typical Forester year. Owners reported a crash, fire or injury in 31 of them. No recalls cover this model year.

On the 2020 Forester, owners describe windshields that crack on their own or from a small chip. One owner in Texas wrote that the windshield cracked on the freeway at 300 miles, and the crack spread across the passenger side. Another windshield cracked while the SUV sat in a parking lot. Subaru wouldn't pay even though the original warranty was still current, that owner wrote. Replacing it cost $1,750.

Beyond the glass, owners mention the engine in 95 complaints, and 53 mention stalling or shutting off. A Texas owner wrote that the auto stop-start feature "drains the battery and alternator too much." The alternator had already been replaced under warranty. Another said that in reverse the SUV would sometimes just idle, then "lunge backwards" once it popped into gear.

ComponentComplaintsMedian miles
Visibility/Wiper2525,000
Unknown Or Other1076,000
Electrical System1032,000

NHTSA complaints cited above: No. 11322502, filed April 2020, Texas · No. 11470186, filed June 2022, Oklahoma · No. 11618439, filed Oct. 2024, Texas · No. 11443999, filed Dec. 2021, Washington.

See the 2020 Subaru Forester on NHTSA

Common Forester Problems Across Model Years

These are the parts that show up most in Forester complaints since 2005, counting every model year.

Visibility/Wiper Problems

Owners filed 1,060 complaints about the visibility and wiper. The 2019 has the most, followed by the 2020. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 9,000 miles.

Engine Problems

Owners filed 790 complaints about the engine. The 2015 has the most, followed by the 2019. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 52,000 miles.

Electrical System Problems

Owners filed 786 complaints about the electrical system. The 2019 has the most, followed by the 2017. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 33,000 miles.

Air Bags Problems

Owners filed 744 complaints about the air bags. The 2017 has the most, followed by the 2015. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 39,500 miles.

Is the Forester Reliable?

Complaints alone can't answer that, because NHTSA doesn't publish how many of each year were sold. What they do show is how each year compares with the rest. Out of 17 Forester model years with enough data, 10 stay close to the typical year. We count close as under 1.5 times. NHTSA lists 40 recall campaigns across the Forester model years on this page.

Every Forester Model Year: Complaints and Recalls

YearComplaintsvs. typicalTop problemMedian milesRecalls
2005930.4×Suspension128,1001
2006880.4×Vehicle Speed Control36,3002
2007740.3×Suspension125,5001
2008500.2×Suspension136,0001
20091780.8×Air Bags60,00017
20102621.2×Seats79,50017
20111470.7×Engine73,50016
20121070.5×Engine86,00015
2013780.4×Engine82,00012
20144031.9×Suspension55,6002
20156172.9×Engine46,3003
20164161.9×Air Bags40,0003
20175942.8×Air Bags30,0001
20184992.3×Visibility/Wiper18,0003
20198343.9×Visibility/Wiper8,0003
20206042.8×Visibility/Wiper5,0000
20212151.0×Visibility/Wiper2,0000
2022100too newVisibility/Wiper—1
202376too newForward Collision Avoidance15,0001
202431too newAir Bags—2
2025102too newVisibility/Wiper1,0003
202635too newElectrical System6,0004

A recall campaign can cover several models, and its count of affected vehicles applies to the whole campaign.

How We Count Complaints

Each complaint is counted once, even when NHTSA's file lists it under several parts. A year's figure is its complaints divided by the median Forester year from 2005 to 2021. The data comes from NHTSA's public files, downloaded on Nov. 11, 2026. Read the full methodology.