CPU Hunter

All models › midsize SUVs › Toyota Highlander

Toyota Highlander Years to Avoid? What NHTSA Complaints Show

The 2021 Highlander drew 2.5 times the complaints of a typical Highlander year. Owners filed 539 complaints about it with NHTSA, against a median of 216 for the model. Problems with the power train came up most, in 233 of them. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 59,700 miles. The 2019 and 2008 also stand out.

These are complaints owners filed with NHTSA, not verified failures, and they aren't adjusted for how many of each year were sold. We compare Highlander years with each other, never with other models. How we count.

typical year = 1.0×2005: 224 complaints, 1.04× the typical year052006: 279 complaints, 1.29× the typical year062007: 124 complaints, 0.57× the typical year072008: 406 complaints, 1.88× the typical year082009: 134 complaints, 0.62× the typical year092010: 216 complaints, 1× the typical year102011: 182 complaints, 0.84× the typical year112012: 182 complaints, 0.84× the typical year122013: 207 complaints, 0.96× the typical year132014: 136 complaints, 0.63× the typical year142015: 193 complaints, 0.89× the typical year152016: 111 complaints, 0.51× the typical year162017: 272 complaints, 1.26× the typical year172018: 276 complaints, 1.28× the typical year182019: 511 complaints, 2.37× the typical year192020: 323 complaints, 1.5× the typical year202021: 539 complaints, 2.5× the typical year212022: 267 complaints, 1.24× the typical year222023: 192 complaints, 0.89× the typical year232024: 43 complaints, 0.2× the typical year242025: 11 complaints, 0.05× the typical year252026: 4 complaints, 0.02× the typical year26
Complaints filed with NHTSA per model year, divided by the median year of this model (2005–2021). Grey bars: fewer than 30 complaints, or 2022 and newer, too recent to compare. Labels are model years ('17 = 2017).

Which Highlander Years Have the Most Complaints?

2021 Highlander: Power Train Problems

Owners reported a crash, fire or injury in 28 of them. There are 4 recalls on this model year.

In 201 complaints about the 2021 Highlander, owners mention a noise, a clunk, a rattle, grinding or whining. A Texas owner heard a whining noise that got louder with speed, and the dealer said the SUV needed a new transmission. It had 67,219 miles. Another heard a whine when accelerating and felt rough shifts pulling away from a stop at 60,000 miles. That dealer also said it needed a new transmission, and a warranty company's test drive agreed.

Owners mention the transmission, gears or shifting in 242 complaints. No recall on this year covers the transmission. A Virginia owner pointed to a Toyota service bulletin, T-SB-0008-21, on the UA80 transmission. Under recall 26V128000, the second-row seat backs may not lock in place, and dealers replace the return springs in the recliners, free of charge. It's a phased recall. Owner letters were mailed on Sept. 9, 2026.

ComponentComplaintsMedian miles
Power Train23359,700
Service Brakes6714,900
Unknown Or Other67—
Recalls for the 2021 Highlander (4)
  • 23V720000 · Structure · 2023-10-26. A detached front bumper cover can become a road hazard, increasing the risk of a crash.
  • 23V865000 · Air Bags · 2023-12-20. An air bag that does not deploy during a crash increases the risk of injury.
  • 24V452000 · Tires · 2024-06-18. Tires with an insufficient load rating can be overloaded and fail, increasing the risk of a crash.
  • 26V128000 · Seats · 2026-03-05. A seat back that fails to lock may not properly restrain an occupant during a crash, increasing the risk of injury.

NHTSA complaints cited above: No. 11713091, filed Jan. 2026, Texas · No. 11699558, filed Nov. 2025, New Jersey · No. 11697299, filed Nov. 2025, Virginia.

See the 2021 Toyota Highlander on NHTSA

2019 Highlander: Power Train Problems

The 2019 drew 511 complaints. That's 2.4 times a typical Highlander year. Owners reported a crash, fire or injury in 24 of them. There are 3 recalls on this model year.

With less than 84,000 miles on it, one 2019 Highlander in New York started whining while accelerating. The dealer said it needed a new transmission, at about $9,300. Another owner's transmission failed on the road at just over 70,000 miles. The SUV was left stuck. A third owner, at 128,000 miles, wrote that the transmission whine gets worse with acceleration and is so loud on the freeway that the SUV is almost undriveable.

Owners mention acceleration, hesitation or lost power in 133 complaints. At 4,000 miles, an owner in Tennessee wrote of a delay between pushing the gas pedal and the SUV actually speeding up, sometimes with a jerk. The two fuel pump recalls on this year, 20V012000 and 20V682000, cover a low-pressure pump inside the tank that can fail and stall the engine. Dealers replace the pump, free of charge. No recall on the 2019 covers the transmission.

ComponentComplaintsMedian miles
Power Train21765,000
Fuel/Propulsion System896,300
Unknown Or Other834,100
Recalls for the 2019 Highlander (3)
  • 19V244000 · Equipment · 2019-03-27. If the driver cannot read the label, they may unknowingly overload the vehicle, increasing the risk of a crash.
  • 20V012000 · Fuel System, Gasoline · 2020-01-13. If the fuel pump fails, the engine can stall while driving, increasing the risk of a crash.
  • 20V682000 · Fuel System, Gasoline · 2020-11-04. If the fuel pump fails, the engine can stall while driving, increasing the risk of a crash.

NHTSA complaints cited above: No. 11713029, filed Jan. 2026, New York · No. 11678450, filed Aug. 2025, New York · No. 11712854, filed Jan. 2026, Arizona · No. 11364068, filed Oct. 2020, Tennessee.

See the 2019 Toyota Highlander on NHTSA

2008 Highlander: Service Brakes Problems

The 2008 drew 406 complaints. That's 1.9 times a typical Highlander year. Owners reported a crash, fire or injury in 59 of them. There are 11 recalls on this model year.

On the 2008 Highlander, owners mention the brakes in 116 complaints. A California owner started the SUV on a sloped daycare driveway, and it rolled backward even with a foot on the brake. The emergency brake stopped it. That was at 26,000 miles. A Highlander Hybrid owner got Check ABS and Brake Malfunction warnings, felt a grinding, and the screen said to "stop the vehicle in a safe place immediately, and contact a dealer." None of this year's recalls covers the brakes.

Owners mention air bags in 59 complaints. A Georgia owner's air bag light came on at 122,856 miles and stayed on after the dealer did the side curtain air bag recall. There are two air bag recalls on this year. Recall 11V245000 replaces the air bag sensor assembly, free of charge, because faulty roll sensors could set off the curtain air bags and seat belt pretensioners. Recall 14V168000 covers a cable in the steering column that can be damaged as the wheel turns and leave the driver's air bag deactivated.

ComponentComplaintsMedian miles
Service Brakes67155,000
Air Bags5878,000
Engine58112,500
Recalls for the 2008 Highlander (11)
  • 08V181000 · Seat Belts · 2008-04-18. HOWEVER, FOR THE TWO THIRD ROW DSP'S ON THESE VEHICLES, THE ALR MODE DEACTIVATES BEFORE THE WEBBING IS FULLY RETRACTED, SO THAT IT WILL NOT LOCK WHEN CERTAIN REAR-FACING CRS'S THAT HAVE A SHORT SEAT BELT ROUTING PATH ARE INSTALLED IN THE VEHICLE. THIS CAN ALLOW THE SEAT BELT WEBBING TO SPOOL OUT DURING NORMAL DRIVING MANEUVERS, WHICH COULD AFFECT THE STABILITY OF A CHILD RESTRAINT INSTALLED AT THOSE SEATING POSITIONS. AS SUCH, THIS COULD DISCOURAGE THE USE OF A CHILD RESTRAINT AND IN THE EVENT OF A CRASH, THE CHILD MAY NOT BE ADEQUATELY PROTECTED POSSIBLY RESULTING IN INJURY.
  • 09V223000 · Equipment · 2009-06-15. INCORRECT LOAD CARRYING CAPACITY MODIFICATION LABELS COULD RESULT IN THE VEHICLE BEING OVERLOADED, INCREASING THE RISK OF A CRASH.
  • 10V023000 · Vehicle Speed Control · 2010-01-27. A STUCK OPEN ACCELERATOR PEDAL MAY RESULT IN VERY HIGH VEHICLE SPEEDS AND MAKE IT DIFFICULT TO STOP THE VEHICLE, WHICH COULD CAUSE A CRASH, SERIOUS INJURY OR DEATH.
  • 10V035000 · Equipment · 2010-02-03. THIS DOES NOT MEET THE STANDARD REQUIREMENTS.
  • 10V036000 · Equipment · 2010-02-03. A DRIVER MAY OVERLOAD A VEHICLE WHICH MAY INCREASE THE RISK OF A CRASH.
  • 11V245000 · Air Bags · 2011-04-21. INADVERTENT ACTIVATION OF THE CSA AND/OR THE SEAT BELT PRETENSIONER CAN CAUSE INJURY TO A VEHICLE OCCUPANT.
  • 12V491000 · Visibility · 2012-10-10. If the switch overheats, it may melt, possibly resulting in a fire.
  • 14V168000 · Air Bags · 2014-04-09. If the FFC is damaged, connectivity to the driver's air bag module could be lost and the air bag deactivated. The failure of the driver's air bag to deploy in the event of a crash that typically necessitates deployment increases the risk of injury to the driver.
  • 14V743000 · Seats · 2014-11-19. Damage to the seat heater wiring could cause the wires to short, increasing the risk of the seat burning and causing personal injury to the occupant.
  • 15V689000 · Visibility · 2015-10-22. If the sliding electrical contacts are not protected by lubricant, debris and moisture that get into the switch may cause a short circuit and the switch assembly may overheat and melt, increasing the risk of a fire.
  • 16V396000 · Seats · 2016-06-02. If damaged, the copper strand heating element may short circuit, increasing the risk of a fire.

NHTSA complaints cited above: No. 10312489, filed Feb. 2010, California · No. 11442547, filed Dec. 2021, Arkansas · No. 10484825, filed Nov. 2012, Georgia.

See the 2008 Toyota Highlander on NHTSA

Common Highlander Problems Across Model Years

These are the parts that show up most in Highlander complaints since 2005, counting every model year.

Power Train Problems

Owners filed 972 complaints about the power train. The 2021 has the most, followed by the 2019. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 43,100 miles.

Electrical System Problems

Owners filed 585 complaints about the electrical system. The 2019 has the most, followed by the 2010. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 48,900 miles.

Service Brakes Problems

Owners filed 572 complaints about the service brakes. The 2006 has the most, followed by the 2008. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 70,000 miles.

Engine Problems

Owners filed 478 complaints about the engine. The 2019 has the most, followed by the 2008. Of those that list a mileage, half came in under 59,000 miles.

Is the Highlander Reliable?

Complaints alone can't answer that, because NHTSA doesn't publish how many of each year were sold. What they do show is how each year compares with the rest. Out of 17 Highlander model years with enough data, 13 stay close to the typical year. We count close as under 1.5 times. NHTSA lists 47 recall campaigns across the Highlander model years on this page.

Every Highlander Model Year: Complaints and Recalls

YearComplaintsvs. typicalTop problemMedian milesRecalls
20052241.0×Power Train45,0006
20062791.3×Service Brakes150,5007
20071240.6×Service Brakes127,0004
20084061.9×Service Brakes155,00011
20091340.6×Engine82,5009
20102161.0×Electrical System66,00010
20111820.8×Steering85,0005
20121820.8×Steering68,0002
20132071.0×Steering54,4003
20141360.6×Electrical System40,0004
20151930.9×Electrical System41,0001
20161110.5×Service Brakes26,5002
20172721.3×Power Train20,0003
20182761.3×Power Train95,2004
20195112.4×Power Train65,0003
20203231.5×Power Train73,0004
20215392.5×Power Train59,7004
2022267too newPower Train105,0005
2023192too newStructure11,9009
202443too newService Brakes—7
202511too newVehicle Speed Control15,0004
20264too newBack Over Prevention—0

A recall campaign can cover several models, and its count of affected vehicles applies to the whole campaign.

How We Count Complaints

Each complaint is counted once, even when NHTSA's file lists it under several parts. A year's figure is its complaints divided by the median Highlander year from 2005 to 2021. The data comes from NHTSA's public files, downloaded on Nov. 11, 2026. Read the full methodology.